|
The American Electrology Association (AEA) has been informed that the Food and
Drug Administration (FDA) has to-date granted six lasers and one pulsed-light device
clearance to market for hair removal. The AEA believes that additional devices will be
cleared in the near future.
The AEA views laser hair removal as a novel concept; however, neither the manufacturers nor the FDA have provided the AEA with the laboratory and clinical studies upon
which the clearance to market decision was based. Therefore, the AEA cannot attest to
the safety and effectiveness of this laser technology at this time. Some of the concerns that
the AEA has raised in the past regarding the use of lasers for hair removal include:
- Safety of the tissue surrounding the follicle.
- High incidence of hyper/hypopigmentation, which may last for months after
treatment. Exposure to sun too soon after treatment can cause the skin to
heal a darker shade than normal skin.
- Skin anomalies, such as herpes, etc. have been shown to worsen on lasered skin.
- Unknown long-term adverse effects on the skin from potentially many years of
repeated irradiation.
- Lack of training required for laser technicians.
- Lack of dermatological knowledge by technicians which would enable them to
distinguish between a potential skin cancer and a harmless eruption. In the case
of cancerous moles, the cancer may metastasize invisibly once the surface evidence
has been removed by the laser. Eradicating a skin lesion and leaving
no specimen available for laboratory study makes proper diagnosis after removal
impossible.
- Research studies have confirmed that the smoke plume contains toxic gases and
vapors. At high concentration, the smoke may cause ocular and upper respiratory
tract irritation in health care personnel; it may also create visual problems for the
surgeon.
- Scientific proof regarding lack of permanence. The few studies that are available
have revealed a very rapid and nearly complete regrowth of hair, typically within
2 to 6 months after a single treatment. Multiple treatments have not been
demonstrated to significantly improve results.
- Poor cost-to-benefit ratio for patients. Treatment packages often cost as much
as a full course of electrolysis, even though electrolysis results are permanent and
laser results are temporary.
Laser hair removal is an experimental therapy and the first generation of patients are
unwitting test subjects for the manufacturers. Laser manufacturers are exerting a tremen-
dous public relations campaign intended to lead an unknowing public to believe this new
technology is the gateway to less painful, faster and permanent hair removal.
AEA has grave concerns regarding the standards ofpatient care. In this rapidly evolving
and entirely unregulated medical specialty, any physician, or his on-the-j ob trained employ-
ees, can use a laser on patients the very same day of purchase, with no more training than
the instructions offered by the manufacturer's sales representative.
The AEA will endorse new technology only after a thorough review of laboratory and
clinical studies that conclusively demonstrate safety and effectiveness (permanence). We
will then work with government regulators and allied health professions to establish the
regulations and trainingprograms thatwill ensure that ourmembers canprovide treatments
meeting the highest standards of patient care.
AMA SPEAKS TO THE USE OF LASERS:
The American Medical Association (AMA) has issued a position statement, "H-475.988 and
H-475.989 Laser Surgery" which states that the organization "supports the position that
revision, destruction, incision or other structural alterations ofhumantissue is surgery".
The Association "adopts the policy that laser surgery should be
performed only by individuals licensed to practice medicine and surgery, or by those
categories of practitioners licensed by the state to perform surgical services."
The AMA further "encourages state medical associations to support
state legislation and rule-making in support of this policy."
More Articles:
Advantages in Electroloysis: » »
Glamour Magazine Writes: » »
|